← All work

Techno-economic analysis

Costing the strategy before you tool it

Barros & Moreira, a Portuguese manufacturer of flushing systems, had to choose a product strategy for a new range before a single tool was cut. We benchmarked two competing strategies technically and economically and set them side by side in a SWOT, so the choice was made on evidence rather than instinct.

The challenge

Barros & Moreira faced a strategic product decision for a new range of flushing systems: how best to cover a spread of market requirements. Two development branches were on the table: a pair of simpler, cheaper products that each serve part of the market, or a single, more complex product flexible enough to answer more requirements on its own. The first keeps each product cheap but doubles production complexity; the second carries a higher unit cost yet covers more of the market with one line. Picking wrong is expensive in tooling and production, so the goal was to make the call early, on evidence rather than instinct.

What we did

  • Benchmarked competitor and candidate products on technical and economic terms to compare the two strategies like for like.
  • Translated the technical picture into unit cost and required investment, normalising every option for an apples-to-apples comparison.
  • Captured the strategic trade-offs the numbers alone miss in a SWOT.

Approach

1. Technical benchmark

We reverse-engineered competitor and candidate products, counting components, weighing raw material by family and estimating production cost. We then benchmarked real-world performance in a standard application. That turned each option into a comparable bill of materials and a like-for-like performance baseline.

ComponentsPlastic32Chromed plastic5Rubber4Metal2Total43Raw-material weight (g)Plastic405Chromed plastic25Rubber27Metal3Total460
Bill of materials for the most complex variant (43 components, 460 g), broken down by material family. It formed the basis of the technical benchmark. Figures simplified for publication.

2. Economic benchmark

We translated the technical picture into unit cost and required investment (raw material, production, mould and assembly-line amortisation), normalising every option so we compared apples to apples. The two strategies, a two-product range and a single flexible product, were costed across each variant.

Two-product rangeSingle flexible product
Market needInteriorUniversalInteriorUniversal
Components17263243
Part weight (g)203297404460
Unit cost (index)100210201317
Tooling (index)100159172224
Both strategies meet the same two market needs (interior and universal). Costs indexed to the lowest variant (= 100); absolute € figures withheld for confidentiality.

3. SWOT

Finally we set the two solutions in a SWOT to capture the strategic trade-offs the numbers alone miss. Chiefly, two products are individually cheaper but multiply production complexity, while the single product costs more per unit yet buys flexibility and broader market coverage.

Outcome

The techno-economic analysis accelerated the strategic decision and the suggested path was implemented. The chosen product then went on to full technical development, from ideation through a calibrated hydraulic model and 3D-printed prototyping to a DOE-validated design. That work is covered in the companion case study, Engineering a flush valve from first principles.

Facing a similar challenge?

A first conversation takes about 30 minutes and costs nothing.